Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Join our Email Newsletter

Sunday Edition


30
Nov
2003
Editorial - History May Be Repeating Itself - Dec 2003


Add this entry to Your Favorites | [0] Favorites [13] Comments

Deon Unthank

Last month’s article brought a lot of conversation, and while this month is not a continuation of that topic, this month’s article should interest the same people. I don’t know if it was coincidence or fate, but I pulled out an old book to read. It was "The History Of Gospel Music" written by Jesse Burt and Duane Allen way back in 1971. I read it back then; however after reading it again things seemed to become clearer. I don’t know if they intended this book to be "prophetic", but in many ways it could be. Actually the authors said that if certain things didn’t happen that we would find Southern Gospel Music in the exact shape that we find it today. I think that most people who know anything of Southern Gospel Music would agree that this music we all love so dearly was in the midst of the greatest growth that it had ever seen in the early 70s, and that if it had continued at that growth we would be giving Country music a run for its money right now. So what happened? What caused a major genre in the music industry to go from rapid growth to floundering in the late 70s and 80s? Well according to the historians of this book, the same problems were happening then as are happening today. First let me add that the historians indicated that if the Gospel Music industry did not accept the changes that were inevitably going to happen that the industry would cease to grow like it had been. What were those changes? Well the music was changing. They were actually adding guitars and drums. Then there was the hair. Some of the singers had hair an inch or two over their ears. There was an outcry that these changes would be the downfall of Gospel Music. Let me back up a bit and say that there was no "Southern Gospel Music" back then. The historians referred to it as "Gospel Music." It seems that it was OK for hair to be long, just not in the style that the younger people wanted to wear it. Does this sound like history repeating itself? It sure does to me. Let’s see, the instruments are OK today as long as they are not played on a mini disc or CD player. Those tracks will be the downfall of SGM. It’s not the length of the hair, but that spiked hair, which may happen to be in style for younger people that has no place on the SGM stage. Does that sound like history repeating itself? It sure does to me. One last thing. One of the best things that happened to Gospel Music back in the 70s was the formation of the Gospel Music Aassociation, an organization that was formed to work with the music industry in general to further this great genre. Now we can argue all day whether the GMA was stolen from us or if we walked away from it, but the fact remains that we have no governing body to help promote SGM in the music industry in general. While the GMA has been making attempts to include SGM again we seem to want to snub any advances that they make toward us. Is history repeating itself again? It sure sounds like it to me. In just one instance, and there are many, the GMA has been trying to include SGM in it’s radio seminars where leaders in radio from all genres, not just CCM are brought in to give much needed information that could certainly help one of the most struggling areas of this genre, but there haven’t even been enough interest to merit keeping the offer open. Is history repeating itself? The fact is we need an organization that can do for us what the GMA is doing for every other Christian music genre. The organizations that we have are not making an impact on the music industry. I don’t know if we need to organize another Association or just swallow our pride and get involved in the GMA again, but it looks to me like history is repeating itself. I would encourage everyone who possibly can to get a copy of "The History Of Gospel Music". I know it’s out of print, but everyone in this industry needs to read it. Let's not let History repeat itself!

Reader Comments

Great article! This is a statement I truly believe in: "If you always do what you've always done, you'll always get what you've always got." Sounds like SGM industry has taken their one talent and went and burried it!


Commented by Ben Scroggs On 12/01/2003
James Hales's avatar Excellent article Deon. Very timely.


Commented by On 12/02/2003
Good article and I agree with you all the way. I'm glad the lean days of the 80's are behind us. However there will always be folks who have something negative to say about anything that is new or innovative. We just need to pray for them.


Commented by judy mcgill On 12/06/2003
Organization would certainly be helpful. Of course, organization without unity would not be any good. But most of what ails Southern Gospel music can be fixed with music instruction, some creativity, a little open mindedness, and hearts that are right with God. However, nothing will be gained be either holding onto the traditional or by following the provocative and trendy. What we really need is music that comes from the honest heart and creative mind that Jesus Christ gives his people.

If we live in the Spirit, let us also walk in the Spirit

- Galatians 5:25

Visit My Website



Commented by Keith Prater On 12/06/2003
Deon,
I am a part of the music committee for GMA.I honestly feel we are making a strong attempt to embrace all genres.I would love to see the other major labels and artist join and begin their support.During this years Dove Awards screenings we were scratching our heads,(We couldnt understand why the majors had not submitted their best product-What an injustice for the artist.If we dont hear it-we can send it on through) I do wish we could find some way to help Southern and Bluegrass more involved.

Rick Hendrix


Commented by Rick Hendrix On 12/08/2003
Deon Unthank's avatar Rick,

I am glad that you picked up on that segment of the article. For the life of me, I cannot figure out why this bitterness and hatred for the GMA continues to flourish in SGM. It's been going on for 30 years now, and it hasn't accompished one thing, except drive us further into the woodwork.
I guess this there is going to be no change in thinking in SGM until this present older leadership has made the trip to heaven, and by then it will no doubt be too late.

Deon Unthank
SoGospelNews.com
My Blog

Some people are like Slinkys… Not really good for anything, but they
still bring a smile to your face when you push them down a flight of stairs - Author Unknown



Commented by On 12/09/2003
I like progressive music if it is done well and if it isn't just a knock-off of a mainstream style. I also believe that being part of an association like the GMA is a good thing. But I believe that the reason so many are so against the GMA is because they feel that those who have embraced CCM are metaphorically embracing the skunk. Many of the things CCM artists do are against the religious doctrines of many who enjoy Southern Gospel music. These Southern Gospel music fans do not want to embrace the skunk. The rift between Southern Gospel and the GMA will not be mended until the GMA recognized the validity of these SG fans' complaint. It has to be admitted that CCM has flourished by cozying up to the sin of the world, and you cannot fault those who do not want to do that. If the GMA would admit that it has erred by cozying up to the world, I'm sure that many in SG would accept it with open arms.

If we live in the Spirit, let us also walk in the Spirit

- Galatians 5:25

Visit My Website



Commented by Keith Prater On 12/09/2003
Deon Unthank's avatar Actually, Keith, that has nothing to do with why SGM abhors the GMA

Deon Unthank
SoGospelNews.com
My Blog

Some people are like Slinkys… Not really good for anything, but they
still bring a smile to your face when you push them down a flight of stairs - Author Unknown



Commented by On 12/09/2003
Deon, great article. I have my dad's copy of that book at home and HIGHLY recommend it to anyone wanting to know more about SGM. After reading your article, I think I will have to pull the book out and read it again.


Commented by On 12/16/2003
"It has to be admitted that CCM has flourished by cozying up to the sin of the world, and you cannot fault those who do not want to do that. "

Keith, i don't know how long you've been around the southern gospel industry
, but it's not perfect either. Some SG artist don't live a Godly life as much as some ccm artists do. It's not fair to judge ccm when you definately don't have the facts on some in the sgma.


Commented by On 12/16/2003
Page 1 of 2 Comment Pages  1 2 >

Add Comments

If you are seeing this form you are not a Member or have not logged in. Why not consider becoming a Member?

Membership allows you to have a prepared signature of your choice applied to every comment you make, as well as the ability to choose an avatar to display next to your name to help identify your posts. Members are also given opportunity to vote weekly in our Weekly Chart as well as special Members Only contests, polls and giveaways during the year. If you are already a member, login here, otherwise please register here.

**Note: Forums membership is a seperate membership.

By posting you agree to our Comments Policy

Name:
Email:
Location:
URL:
Comment:
Remember my personal information
Notify me of follow-up comments?
Please enter the word you see in the image below: