Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Join our Email Newsletter
Compassion International

Sunday Edition


13
Mar
2004
Ministry Vs Entertainment - Mar 2004


Add this entry to Your Favorites | [0] Favorites [21] Comments

Scott Bandy

If you are in or around Southern Gospel Music for any period of time you will no doubt run into the debate over Entertainment versus Ministry. This long drawn out debate has set me pondering this age old question. Which is it? Is there a place for good wholesome Christian entertainment or should we be totally ministry driven? Perhaps the answer is not really up to us? Or should I say, it's not really up to the artist. Perhaps both are happening at the same time and it is impossible to separate the two.

God has given us all talents and gifts. He wants us to use these gifts that he's given us. Not all are called to preach or be pastors. All of us however are called into the ministry! Whether we are grocery store clerks or full time pastors, we all have been given the same Great Committion!

However, is it really up to the artist to decide whether his song is entertaining or ministering? It seems to me that the artist's job is to sing his songs to the best of the ability God has given him. God then will choose who is ministered to. It is the individual hearing the song that ultimately decides whether it is ministry or entertainment.

I look back at the single greatest songwriter to ever live, King David! He wrote songs that have blessed us unendingly! However, did David know that while he was writing his great songs that someone would write them down and put them in the Bible to be read and sang thousands of years later? How could he? It seems to me that David wrote and sang songs from his heart. Many of his songs were sung out of great despair and agony. I'm sure that in his mind these songs were not coming from him with the intention to minister to someone else. He sang these songs for himself, as prayers to God in his deepest sorrow. Now thousands of years later, we have these great songs that give us hope and inspiration and minister to our souls on a daily basis. Did David know that in his deepest agonies he was declaring prophecy for the soon to come Messiah, or was he just despairing and God used his talent as a songwriter to bring forth a great song of ministry? David is just one great talent that probably never considered himself a minister or to have a ministry. He simply sang and wrote about what he held deep in his heart!

There have been many songs that have deeply touched and ministered to my soul. However, not every song ever written about Jesus or God or The Holy Spirit has ministered to me. Some bring joy, hope and inspiration but not so much a ministry to my soul! So many groups today declare they are in it for the ministry. But, it seems that they are really just doing what God has given them to do. Singers sing, preachers preach, salesmen sell! The heart receiving the message in the song is what decides whether or not it is ministry! Who can view what the heart needs besides God? He knows who needs to be ministered to by a song. To those who don't need it, it is simply great music or in other words, great Christian entertainment!

So if we the artists take ourselves out of the equation and simply sing using our God given gifts, the need for an argument over ministry and entertainment will no longer be needed. Whether we like it or not both are happening at the same time and it is not up to the artist to decide which one is going to happen next. God can use anything to minister to someone! Let's not forget he used a donkey to knock Paul off his high horse. Ministry can happen in a secular song as well as a gospel song!

Let's put the focus on using our gifts to the best of our ability and remove the pride in us that says we have to be a ministry to sing Gospel music. Once again, ministry is not up to us when it comes to music. Ministry is in the heart of those receiving that music!

Reader Comments

Sott, I agree with you. Even someone standing and preaching is intertainment to some people. I believe a group or soloist must be somewhat entertaining to be successful with thier ministry.


Commented by On 03/16/2004
I agree with the general message of the article. But I am not sure that you can classify true music as entertainment. Do you consider a beautiful sunset entertainment? Or a pretty flower? What about the purple mountains' majesty? These things are the beauties of nature. Music should also be one of nature's beauties. Entertainment is the stimulation of the flesh to excitement. Once we reduce music to entertainment, we have removed it from what God intended it to be.

If we live in the Spirit, let us also walk in the Spirit

- Galatians 5:25

My Blog



Commented by Keith Prater On 03/19/2004
Good point! It's not up to us. We are to do what God has called us to do and He will take care of the rest.


Commented by On 03/19/2004
Scott - this is something I have really felt strongly about ever since my husband & I started attending the SGM services. I am blessed (entertained) by the singing and testimonies and prayer - therefore it really has become primarily a service (ministry)for me. It's really hard for me to even use the term "concert" - that's much too commercial! SSQ always ministers - they are totally spirit-driven. That's the difference. smile


Commented by On 03/19/2004
Scott - A secular song as well as a gospel song? I think that perhaps you should review your meaning of "MINISTRY".


Commented by On 03/19/2004
Peggy,
I'm sorry you feel that way but if you don't believe that you can be ministered to by a secular song then you are limiting what God can do. There are a lot of "Secular" songs that can minister just as much as SG songs. Example: Butterfly Kisses by Bob Carlisle, Youth of the Nation by POD, What's this Life For by Creed, My Own Prison by Creed, even Beautiful by Cristina Aguilarra. If you look past the person singing it and listen to the song itself, you will find that ministry can take place in even the oddest places, by people you would not call Ministers! It's all about what the song says to the individual. What ministers to you may not to the next person and what doesn't minister to you can very much so to the next person as well. Ministry is about God knowing what we need on an individual basis. This is why we have a wide variety of song topics and meanings...to reach those who it would minister too. Not every song is going to minister to every person but let's not limit God on who or what he can use!


Commented by On 03/19/2004
I can't say that I have ever been "ministered" to by a "secular song. I have enjoyed some of them, and been entertained by some of them, but never ministered to by any of them. I have had my emotions touched by secular songs, but that is not the same as being ministered to by one.


Commented by On 03/19/2004
"I agree with the general message of the article. But I am not sure that you can classify true music as entertainment. Do you consider a beautiful sunset entertainment? Or a pretty flower? What about the purple mountains' majesty? These things are the beauties of nature. Music should also be one of nature's beauties. Entertainment is the stimulation of the flesh to excitement. Once we reduce music to entertainment, we have removed it from what God intended it to be."

Keith, I would have to disagree!! Do you truly think that the beauty of nature God made can't touch a life, move a soul so deeply that it causes them to re-direct their life? Realize more important things...THAT in itself is ministry!! Webster define's Ministry as "the act of serving". I truly believe God serves me with whatever I need at whatever time I need it!! Why must we limit GOD!?!? If he can speak through a donkey, then I'm sure he can use a "secular" song, or the "purple mountains' majesty, or even the sunset to minister to me. And to answer the question...YES, I've been entertained by the beauty of God's creation!!!! Haven't you ever sat on the back porch and watched the robins play? Or played with a puppy?? Did you go to the Zoo to admire all the animals? How bout get up early one morning to watch the sunrise? OR...better yet, have ya ever gone on vacation to see those great big mountains?? If you didn't go for some sorta entertainment, why did you go?

"Scott - A secular song as well as a gospel song? I think that perhaps you should review your meaning of "MINISTRY"."

Peggy, maybe Scott doesn't need to review his meaning of ministry. Maybe, just maybe God works through ALL things! INCLUDING something you think would be so disgusting, such as a donkey...or secular music! I believe we shouldn't limit God. Think of all the AMAZING blessings you're missing out on!!


Commented by Amy Marie On 03/20/2004
Good article Scott. :thumbsup: It and the comments it has inspired got me thinking. And here's what I came up with when I was doing all that thinking. :light: Perhaps everyone is just splitting hairs unnecessarily on this whole issue. I looked up the words "minister" and "entertain". One use of "minister" was "minister to" ~ to work and care for: attend, do for, serve, or wait on. And a definition of "entertain" was ~ to occupy in an agreeable or pleasing way: amuse, divert, recreate, or regale. Recreate, now there was a word that caught my attention even if I am going to stretch its use a little here. Re-Create ~ to make new or as if new again: furbish, recondition, refresh, refurbish, rejuvenate, renew, renovate, restore, revamp. Now if we look at ministering as serving or caring for and entertaining as creating new life, how could one be a more worthy goal then the other? It looks like two sides of the same coin now to me. Perhaps we forget sometimes that we are just tools. Tools are not supposed to decide how they are to be used in the hands of the one using them, they are just supposed to be available when needed. Course I guess some tools are particular and they can only be used for certain things...ever get frustrated when you can't do something with a tool and it is the only one you have and..... Anyway, there ya have it, my two cents worth!


Commented by On 03/20/2004
Great article Scott.


Commented by On 03/24/2004
Page 1 of 3 Comment Pages  1 2 3 >

Add Comments

If you are seeing this form you are not a Member or have not logged in. Why not consider becoming a Member?

Membership allows you to have a prepared signature of your choice applied to every comment you make, as well as the ability to choose an avatar to display next to your name to help identify your posts. Members are also given opportunity to vote weekly in our Weekly Chart as well as special Members Only contests, polls and giveaways during the year. If you are already a member, login here, otherwise please register here.

**Note: Forums membership is a seperate membership.

By posting you agree to our Comments Policy

Name:
Email:
Location:
URL:
Comment:
Remember my personal information
Notify me of follow-up comments?
Please enter the word you see in the image below: